A learning experience

A learning experience

As I sit here in an airport, I can look back on the last few days which have been a learning experience for me. Somethings have been revelations, others simply what I already knew but spelled out in front of me for the first time. Techniques such as wiring are learnt by repetition and have become part of my physical memory as opposed to the conscious part of my easily distracted brain.
At the first Bonsai Colloquium (I had to look it up) in Rochester NY, organised by the half centurion Bill Valavanis, the artiste de jour and all round good egg Ryan Neil gave a very interesting lecture on wiring. Confessing to me that he hadn’t prepared much for it, I told him that “if you can’t talk for two hours off the cuff about pretty much any topic, then you can’t call yourself a professional”…I think that I was trying to convince myself more than him, but he smiled and got on with it in the consummate way that he has. During the hour that he spoke on wiring I learnt that putting into words that which I knew innately as physical memory, gleaned over years of repetition; was actually very very difficult. It also highlights the fact that fundamental techniques such as wiring, repotting, and pruning can only be learnt properly through repetition, repetition and more of the above. It was the line

When wiring branches in pairs, one of the wires goes clockwise and the other counter clockwise

Followed by me air-wiring a pair of branches, that made me go….oh yeah. It seems so obvious but yet I had never actually said it myself.
My own talks consisted of a compressed hour of Japanese Aesthetics and a satsuki demonstration. I had a powerpoint and a sleepy audience for one and the ability to talk for ages on the other. I would have taken pictures of the demo tree but it didn’t seem appropriate.
Being in the audience for other speakers gives a lot of food for thought, not only on the topic but also the delivery. Last night the inimitable David DeGroot gave a talk at the Upstate NY club evening that I was allowed to sit in on. For those who don’t know David, shame on you. During the first half of his talk I took a great number of notes and some of the things he said were very interesting.

Art is something which creates emotional or intellectual satisfaction

I liked that description, admittedly it is very simple, but it does sum up many aspects of bonsai quite well, the intellectual challenge of creation and cultivation which can be appreciated by a knowledgable audience as well as the more emotive and artistic side of design which can be appreciated by anyone with aesthetic sense.

The best description he gave though really made me think hard.

We don’t look at a painting to see paint on a canvas

So by extrapolation, we do not look at a bonsai to see a tree in a pot?
….and wait for it….BOOM! It may not be the deepest and most metaphysical thing I have ever thought, but damn that is true.

David “whacking off” a black pine.
It wasn’t just intellectually stimulation that was to be had, one of the speakers, Dennis Makashima, managed to make a few of us silently cry with his repeated description of his pruning technique…see above for details.
Overall the experience and conversations have lead me to a re-think in terms of how education in bonsai could be approached. Seeing the level in the US rise so quickly for some, those dedicated few, it has to be replicated at home. For those in the UK, how would you like to be educated? Is there demand for the highest level intellectual and technical rigour? Are there people dedicated enough to practice, practice, practice? Who is willing to take on some new challenges and push the boundaries of what is possible in the UK?
Is this the joker to do it?

See what happens when a bonsai professional has too much free time on his hands? When will my plane leave? Cursed loose rivet.

11 Comments

  1. Tony Tickle 2 years ago

    Great post and beautifully written Peter…

  2. Peter Warren 2 years ago

    Why thank you Tony. I thought it was a little random myself, but thank you.

  3. tofu_junky 2 years ago

    Another excellent piece Peter – bring on the technicalities!!
    More, more, more!! (Please).
    Chris R

  4. bonsaieejit.com 2 years ago

    Random is your style :-)Excellent read, random or not!

  5. Peter Warren 2 years ago

    You may not appreciate the random pruning approach I may or may not take on that new itoigawa of yours in september.
    All jokes aside, you are on of the people I am looking to to become the vanguard of pushing things further…

  6. Grow a Bonsai 2 years ago

    "We do not look at a bonsai to see a tree in a pot" That's a great thought, it may sound simple but sometimes we forget it. Great post.

  7. DaveKirkland 2 years ago

    I don't know if there has ever been UK teaching as you describe it, delivered by a person blessed with two rare gifts; the first – for dedication to learning the techniques and art thoroughly, the second – a passion for effective delivery. We definitely want it. It would transform UK bonsai. So, bring it on Peter – make yourself the 'chosen one' of Bonsai!

  8. Peter Warren 2 years ago

    Careful…we are heading into becoming the king of monkey mountain territory here…

  9. bonsaieejit.com 2 years ago

    I'm yer man :-)

  10. Anonymous 2 years ago

    One sign of a great Teacher is one who loves to learn themselves and is never satisfied they "know it all".
    The Force is strong in this one…

  11. Anonymous 2 years ago

    I actually think that picture of you is the best I've ever seen. I want a massive copy of it to frame and put up in my home immediately.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*